| Location | Item | Value | Total | |
| Start Caves | Underwater cave | Purple gem | 50 | 50 |
| Next to barrel (near ladder) | Blue gem | 100 | 150 | |
| Gardener's House | In attic (secret) | Spice | 40 | 190 |
| Butler's room | Bedside table | Purse | 100 | 290 |
| In footlocker | Ring | 100 | 390 | |
| Study S end of corridor | On floor | Wine | 40 | 430 |
| Room with ship's wheel | Under sofa (secret) | Silver coinstack x 3 | 36 | 476 |
| Purse | 100 | 576 | ||
| Kitchen | On table | Spice | 40 | 616 |
| Above sink | Gold goblets x 3 | 75 | 691 | |
| Inside shelf unit (secret) | Gold coins | 65 | 756 | |
| Bunkroom | Between bunks | Wine | 50 | 806 |
| Above stairs to refrigerator | On shelf | Gold plates x 3 | 150 | 956 |
| Guardpost | On table | Copper coinstack x 2 | 10 | 966 |
| Silver coinstack x 2 | 24 | 990 | ||
| Coin | 20 | 1010 | ||
| Dining room | On table | Candlestick x 3 | 150 | 1160 |
| Music room | On table | Silver flute | 50 | 1210 |
| Workshop | In toolbox | Cuckoo | 150 | 1360 |
| Library | On bookshelf | Book | 50 | 1410 |
| In reading room | Spectacles | 50 | 1460 | |
| Bedroom near library | On dresser | Tiara | 125 | 1585 |
| 2nd guestroom | Bedside table | Gold coinstack x 3 | 75 | 1660 |
| 3rd guestroom | On dresser | Necklace | 200 | 1860 |
| Chapel | Under lectern | Goblet | 15 | 1875 |
| Gaming room | Gaming table | Dice | 50 | 1925 |
| Corner table | Coins | 12 | 1937 | |
| Septic Tank | NE corner | Gold nugget | 100 | 2037 |
| Secret passage (library) | On table | Coins | 62 | 2099 |
| Under south pirate shack | In chest | Spice | 40 | 2139 |
| South pirate shack | On table | Gold coinstack x 3 | 75 | 2214 |
| Purse | 100 | 2314 | ||
| NE pirate shack | Outside, by crates | Gold statue | 75 | 2389 |
| Beside barrel | Tapestry | 150 | 2539 | |
| Upper wooden walkway | Jar x 2 | 40 | 2579 | |
| In footlocker | Mask | 50 | 2629 | |
| NW pirate shack | On table | Gem | 100 | 2729 |
| Tunnel to west | Behind Statue | Jar | 20 | 2749 |
| Cave with crates | On floor | Tapestry | 150 | 2899 |
| In footlocker | Torc | 350 | 3249 | |
| Ship's cabin | Bedside table | Gold nugget | 100 | 3349 |
| In secret | Wine | 50 | 3399 | |
| Ship's hold | Mask | 50 | 3449 | |
| Attic | NW corner | Mask | 50 | 3499 |
| Basement | Between chairs | Crystal | 25 | 3524 |
| Refrigerator | Statue | 15 | 3539 | |
| Graveyard | In bowl | Coin | 20 | 3559 |
| In secret behind tombstone | Tiara | 125 | 3684 | |
| Secret crypt | On tomb (read book) | Medallion | 100 | 3784 |